2009 Contestants Abagail Michaud Miss Hairdresser on Fire Alexandra Dowe Miss Windsor Kiwanis Amanda Whalen Miss Cicero's Sunoco Store Chelsea Yeomans Brookman Plumbing Erica Burke Miss Ashley's Distinctive Jewelry & Gifts Kara Moras Miss Windsor Lions Club Kayla Gegetskas Miss Nunes Quality Plumbing & Heating Kelly Flynn Miss PC Development Group Meagan Golightly Exchange Club Miss Exchange Club